Language Selection

Get healthy now with MedBeds!
Click here to book your session

Protect your whole family with Orgo-Life® Quantum MedBed Energy Technology® devices.

Advertising by Adpathway

         

 Advertising by Adpathway

How to Vote For a Fielding Award: A Study

3 weeks ago 17

PROTECT YOUR DNA WITH QUANTUM TECHNOLOGY

Orgo-Life the new way to the future

  Advertising by Adpathway

Image credit: IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

This article contains my ballot for the Fielding Bible Awards, as revealed today at Sports Info Solutions. But first, if you’ll forgive, a lengthy aside.

For as long as baseball has had defensive metrics, they’ve been maligned. You can see in the earliest box scores how Alexander Cartwright grappled with how to assign the proper amount of virtue and sin into fielding; totals for put-outs, assists, and errors crowded the column space. The countable has always won out over the uncountable, particularly for a sport so dependent on the archaeology of pre-televised box scores for its data, to provide any support for the often biased eyewitnesses of the day. Much of the rest of the data fell away—perhaps unfortunately, since outs created, and its logical next step defensive efficiency, is far from the worst way to measure defensive value—and for a century, our rating system condensed into the simple error, Cartrwight’s value system at its most refined. Players who didn’t make mistakes were good defenders.

When advanced defensive metrics were introduced, they arrived largely to scorn, and common refrains—these numbers from different sources didn’t even compare to each other. (They still don’t, often.) Instead, though, I struggle to imagine how Gold Gloves were decided before those metrics arrived. Sure, there’s a base level of competency that’s easy to sniff out, but once you reach the margins, it’s nearly invisible to the naked eye. In a sense, it’s like voting on manager of the year: You can’t get an appreciation for the sum of a player’s defense in a day, or even a weekend. You’d have to sit with it every day, watch carefully to see what plays one guy makes that another might not quite. And even then, you’re doing that for one club; how could you compare it to the guy in Cleveland, who you’ve seen nine times all year?

And yet we do have to decide who’s good at this, because that’s a little piece of the job. So we have to turn to the numbers, and politely ignore their petty little squabbles and sample-size issues. After all, some of the discrepancy arises not out of inexactitude, but philosophical differences: Do we measure pre-pitch positioning as part of a player’s contribution, or do we measure how difficult the play was at the moment they took their first step? How much do we weigh the value of an outfielder’s or a catcher’s arm, and what do we do when it’s so good that runners prefer not to test it? Can we even trust the scorekeepers on what an error is anymore? (No.) Awards are designed to be subjective—a single point, perceived from a hundred different vantages—despite the fact that metrics, with their tenths and hundredth places, make it all look so precise and objective.

With that rather sizable piece of context out of the way, to my ballot. Except that we’ll have to add one more disclaimer: my own philosophy toward the awards. I tend to approach each award in a different way. The MVP and Cy Young awards I treat as individual, historical accomplishment, and focus primarily on a player’s strict seasonal output more than what they “deserved” in a more peripheral sense. For Rookie of the Year, as I’ve explained before and will do again in a few weeks, my perspective is rather opposite: rookies can’t control their own playing time or environment, so I’m more likely to look at peripherals and underlying traits, rather than sorting by WARP. With defense, I find myself splitting the difference. I’ll use the metrics to determine production, checking with folks in case something activates the spider senses. But these ballots tend to be split by position, and players often play multiple positions, so I don’t want to use straight counting stats to reward the guy who moved around the least. Defensive skill, to me, isn’t a counting stat.

Caveats complete, for real this time. My ballot, with brief explanations behind my thought process:

Read Entire Article

         

        

HOW TO FIGHT BACK WITH THE 5G  

Protect your whole family with Quantum Orgo-Life® devices

  Advertising by Adpathway